Posted on January 17, 2006 at 3:00 PM in @earthlink
Note: The below is an archived entry from Earthling, formerly EarthLink's official blog. The blog itself has been decommissioned and is no longer updated, and comments are trackbacks are no longer accepted.
Google just announced that they've opened up access to part of Googletalk, their instant messenger client, so that it can talk to Vling, EarthLink's instant messenger client. Google and EarthLink have created a federation of companies that believe in letting our messaging systems interoperate with each other. We've invited all other instant messaging systems to join, and we hope that today is the first of many such announcements.
What does that mean?
Up until now, if you were a Vling user, you could only see and communicate with people on your buddylist who use Vling. Very shortly, if you are a Vling user, you will see and be able to send messages to people who use Googletalk as well.
How did it come to this?
It's pretty ridiculous. As far as text messaging goes, I have one friend who uses MSN messenger. One friend. And for that I have to have the MSN instant messaging program open all day (Sorry, Michelle, it's totally worth it). I have a sprinkling of friends who use Yahoo. I have a bunch who use AIM. I have some who use Vling. And still more who use Jabber.
So what that means is, I can't choose which instant text messaging tool I want to use. Apple's Ichat only talks to Jabber and AIM. AIM only talks to AIM. Vling only talks to Vling (and now Googletalk!). Why should that be, when to me, a text conversation is a text conversation. There are programs that will allow you to sign in to multiple networks, but they are pretty clumsy and I don't see why I should have to use them.
It's not like I get any special thrill out of using AOL's network. What really matters to me is what the desktop program behaves like, not what network it is. Shouldn't it all be like e-mail, where I get to pick which e-mail program I want to use, but still get to send e-mail to anyone who uses e-mail?
EarthLink thinks so. And to that end we support open standards and interoperability. We've been beating the drum for years that we should all find a way to let our messaging networks communicate. According to Tom Hsieh, Director of Voice Products and Engineering, the popular response from the other players has amounted to "Go pound sand."
But Google has come forward and said they'd like to create a federation with us, and in so doing iron out a process for bringing new companies in to the group. Everyone has concerns about the potential for spam and abuse, and by working together and seeing how it goes we can make sure that future partners share the same protection we have. We spent a few months building a gateway that lets our network communicate with theirs, and this week it's ready to launch. We can do the same thing for whoever else wants to join.
It's no secret that for us, once the networks are interoperable, one of the neat features we can offer is a unified identity. Today, if you sign up for a free EarthLink e-mail account, your e-mail address can also work for instant messaging and free VOIP phone communications. So if you want to give out your phone number, you just pass along your e-mail address. What enables this is an open standard called SIP, and any company can use it for their VOIP communications. It's much easier than having to remember three different account names.
At one time in the past, there were 3 or more separate e-mail systems that couldn't send e-mail between them. Eventually, those walls fell and today anyone with an SMTP address can send e-mail to anyone else. We're hoping that today's announcement is the beginning of the end of separate, walled-in instant messaging systems. And the same goes for computer-based VOIP systems.
Go here to sign up for Vling and give it a try. When the new system is completely live and tested from our end, I'll update this blog entry.
Comments
This is great news! I've always wondered why I couldn't just IM with whomever I wanted whenever I wanted, and now looks like you guys have found a way to make it work.
Posted by Becky | January 17, 2006 7:41 PM
If you're permitted to say, when will "very soon" be?
Posted by runs with dogs | January 17, 2006 9:06 PM
Thanks for your comment, Becky. Hopefully some of the other IM networks will follow suit.
Runs with dogs:
Last I heard from the team, it was happening soon enough that I probably won't get advanced warning when the work is done. But I'm checking with them again and will post when I hear anything.
Posted by earthling | January 18, 2006 12:27 PM
Do you have it for MAC?
Gary Wolland
Posted by Gary Wolland | January 18, 2006 12:59 PM
Hi Earthling (and other readers),
I'm very pleased to see that Earthlink and Google are being sensible players in what is otherwise a mess.
Until all of this gets hammered out, however, I'd respectfully urge folks to use one of the many programs on the Mac or PC to log into the many IM services simultaneously, or use Meebo (www.meebo.com) on the Web.
On the PC, I use Trillian, and have been very pleased with its stability and usefulness in connecting me to ALL the major IM services (including GoogleTalk) without having to run 6 different programs. I don't remember the names of the similar programs on the Mac, but I know they exist.
Hopefully, as you suggested, this sort of workaround won't be necessary in the future; different IM clients will compete on reliability, functionality, UI, and so on. But in the meantime, at least we have some sane options :)
Posted by Adam | January 18, 2006 1:57 PM
This is very good news, hopefully this trend will continue.
Posted by KJ | January 19, 2006 8:54 PM
I met with Tom Hsieh and Jim Anderson of the voice team, and they are pleased to report that the text messaging interoperability between networks is now working.
There are a couple of issues they are working to resolve, and the software is still in beta so it's not bulletproof yet.
Posted by earthling | January 20, 2006 1:18 PM
Gary:
Thanks for your comment. The product team is looking into a Mac solution, but for now Vling is Windows-only.
Adam:
Point well taken. I haven't been a huge fan of any of the Mac-based clients, but I have used GAIM on XP.
Posted by earthling | January 20, 2006 1:21 PM
Does this mean you are connected to the entire Jabbernetwork, or just Google Talk?
Posted by Sveinung | February 27, 2006 12:59 AM
I have been invited several times by a friend to join gmail but i dont get any response from the google talk people.I was suggesting should they just inform the world that they dont need any more subscribers than to leave the option of adding people to the gmail open
Posted by martin oswald | May 17, 2006 8:01 AM